Call Your Mom

Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah? The Love Triangle Debate We Can’t Quit

Episode Summary

This week on Call Your Mom, Sierra and Holly deep-dive into the ultimate TV love triangles, sparked by their obsession with The Summer I Turned Pretty. From Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah to revisiting the iconic drama of Vampire Diaries, Twilight, One Tree Hill, Dawson’s Creek, and Gossip Girl, they unpack why audiences love the “bad boy vs. good guy” trope. Along the way, they share personal takes on growing up, friendship, settling in relationships, and why sometimes the best choice is choosing yourself. Expect laughter, mom-wisdom, iced coffee recipes, and a few golden retriever husband shoutouts. Whether you’re Team Conrad, Team Stephan, or Team Edward, this episode is for anyone who’s ever debated fictional crushes like they’re real life.

Episode Notes

This week, we’re diving headfirst into the world of love triangles — and trust us, mama holly's opinion will surprise you.

From The Summer I Turned Pretty (Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah) to Vampire Diaries (Stephan or Damon?), Twilight (Edward or Jacob?), One Tree Hill, Dawson’s Creek, and Gossip Girl — Sierra and Holly break down the most iconic “bad boy vs. good guy” debates in TV history. And of course, we’re not just fangirling over fictional crushes. We talk about:

This episode is equal parts fun pop-culture deep dive and real-life mom advice. Whether you’re Team Conrad, Team Damon, or Team Chuck Bass, you’ll feel right at home in this conversation.